Old Westbury: A Memoir

Part VII: Full Circle, 2024-2025

Return to Sender
After my 2006 visit, I never saw the house again, though I often pictured rain drumming on the attic skylight.
Hoping to make contact with whoever might be living there and share my story, I mailed a letter. It came back “Return to Sender: Home Vacant.”

When I called the Old Westbury Post Office, they said the sticker often indicates the house is no longer standing. Not ready to accept this, I spoke with several realtors and learned that in 2020, at the height of COVID-19, the owner couldn't keep up maintenance and had the house demolished.

Only the land remains for sale. The place was gone, but the light endured. Perhaps the cellar still lies buried beneath the earth.

Perhaps the spirits of Charles and his bride roam the land.

But what about Alexa?

Decades later, spurred by the Internet, I set out to find my friend. In the Old Westbury town records, I confirmed my attendance at the elementary school and our family’s residence from September 1959 to the summer of 1960.
Still curious, I searched the address for traces of the Ragsdales. Much to my astonishment, the home was listed as vacant for that entire period. No one had lived there since the Ragsdales left in 1960.

The Return
After learning that the old mansion had been demolished, I felt hollow, as though a part of my soul had vanished with it. It did not seem possible that something so alive in memory could simply cease to exist. For months, I tried to accept it, reminding myself that places, like people, have their time. Yet the thought of its absence kept tugging at me, much like the time I flew to New York two days after 9/11 to see for myself that the Twin Towers had truly disappeared into thin air. But this loss felt more personal. Once again, I needed to witness it with my own eyes.

From the West Coast, I flew to New York, rented a car, and drove straight to Old Westbury, not to look at what once was, but to stand once more on the ground that had held so many beginnings. I parked on Wheatley Road to relive the familiar experience of walking to the house from the bus stop, just as I had nearly sixty years ago.

With my backpack slung over my shoulder, I walked down the wooded road that once led to Alexa’s driveway. The path was quieter now, yet the same fragrance of autumn lingered in the air while the old oaks swayed overhead.

The Presence
Before turning left where the driveway once began, I noticed a real estate sign swinging gently in the wind, its corners weathered and its colors fading. “Build Your Own 5+ Acre Dream Mansion,” it read in bold letters, with a phone number and the realtor’s name neatly printed below. The sign’s invitation felt like both a mockery and a strange promise.

I followed the old path, half expecting to hear the crunch of gravel beneath my shoes, but found only wild grass, tangled weeds, and wildflowers.

I stood staring, rooted in disbelief. The great arching oaks were gone. This was where Alexa and I once strolled for hot chocolate beneath branches that had seemed to touch the sky. 

I stepped closer until I reached the place where I remembered the house had stood. It was gone, leaving only a faint outline of concrete tracing its foundation. I had come seeking proof of loss, but what I found instead was presence itself. In that instant, I understood that absence could hold its own kind of life. Even in its silence, the house was alive in memory, its spirit woven through the air and soil.

In my mind, the original Art Deco mansion still hovered there, luminous and unreal, like a white mirage suspended against time. I sensed something achingly familiar in the autumn wind.

At that moment, the sun slipped through the clouds, a single ray finding the spot where the mosaic dome once caught its glow, as though the sun itself had forgotten the house was gone and continued shining through the same portal of memory.

The Descent
As I walked the area where the house had once stood, I studied the ground like an archaeologist of memory. My pulse quickened as I began to notice remnants: a fragment of mosaic tile, a piece of Carrara marble, cobalt blue ceramic from the old kitchen stove, a wooden dollhouse chair, and a piece of black-painted wrought iron that had once supported the trellis beneath the terraces. Each was small yet significant, a treasure to me.

It was as though the old mansion were sending me souvenirs, fragments of a final message. Each fragment drew me inward, merging past and present until the land itself seemed to speak.

The air grew still, and something subtle moved below me. The ground softened beneath me, as though the earth itself had drawn breath. I pressed my palm into the soil. The sensation returned, steady and low, like a heartbeat moving through the earth.

I went to my knees, my ear against the earth. The soil was warm, almost alive. At first, there was only silence, then a faint rhythm, distant and elusive, like the echo of music, the pulse of life moving deep below.

The sound faded, but I stayed there, unwilling to move, my cheek resting against the cool earth. The stillness thickened, the kind that comes before dusk, when even the birds fall quiet. The light softened to amber, then deepened into rose. Long shadows reached toward me, offering a quiet kind of comfort.

When I lifted my head, the sky above the clearing had turned violet. A cool hush lingered, scented with damp leaves and soil. I could still sense the subtle thrum beneath my feet. For an instant, I questioned my sanity. Perhaps I was lightheaded from kneeling so long or simply hungry after the flight. But I swear I saw the white stucco mansion rise from the rubble, as if summoned to resurrect.

I heard a faint rustle, the sound of leaves shifting behind me. A chill ran up my spine and I froze, listening. Was it an animal, a person? I turned sharply, half expecting to see someone there. The clearing was empty, yet the atmosphere had changed. The air had become charged, almost electric, and something unseen seemed to step closer. 

The sensation was not frightening, only intimate and familiar, as though the land itself had taken a breath and was waiting for me to listen.

Then I saw her, or thought I did, a blonde figure standing at the edge of the trees, her hair caught in the fading light. She appeared both near and far, transparent yet somehow real. Maybe it was the trick of shadows, or perhaps not. My heart quickened. Was it Alexa? The thought rose before I could stop it. I whispered into the wind, “Is it you?”

The truth had finally surfaced, yet something deeper still called from beneath the soil. What waited ahead was more than discovery; it was reckoning.

Stay tuned for July: The search returns to the land itself, where memory and spirit linger, waiting to be heard.