Therapy When Fine Isn’t Good Enough

Because something in you knows it could feel better. by Dr. Melissa Carman, PhD, LMHC

Dr. Melissa Carman at her office at Jennings House Wellness Center

Recently, I began working with a high-functioning executive who shared that he had never considered counseling before. He described long, sleepless nights spent tossing and turning over difficult conversations and the weight of his responsibilities. He told me he loved his family and took pride in his career, yet also admitted that he felt distant, not only from the people he cared about most, but from himself.

He said something that stayed with me:
"I thought this was just who I am. I didn’t think anything was wrong with me. But I also didn’t think it could be different."

What brought him in was not a diagnosis. It was not a crisis. His wife had not issued an ultimatum. It was a quiet internal whisper that maybe his life, and the way he felt within it, could be better than this. Maybe he could feel more at ease in his mind, more connected to the people he loves, and more present in his own life. It was not dramatic. It was a sliver of hope, and that was enough.

This is one of the most common patterns I see in my work. Many adults, especially parents and professionals, have learned to function at a high level while quietly carrying anxiety, disconnection, or undiagnosed neurodivergence. One in five adults in the U.S. lives with a diagnosable mental health condition, yet many go years without seeking help.
 
Because they have not experienced a crisis, they assume that what they feel is simply part of life. They bring their children to therapy, but they just keep going. They keep coping, reinforcing the patterns they have spent years perfecting. They keep showing up for everyone else in their lives. Quietly, though, they sense something is off.

I understand this pattern personally. I was diagnosed with ADHD in my late thirties. I am a therapist, trained in the field and surrounded by the language of mental health every day, yet I still missed it in myself. Like many others, I was able to function well and even successfully. I had systems, drive, and coping mechanisms. What I did not have was clarity about how much effort it was costing me to appear fine as I struggled to meet deadlines, organize my life (let alone my closet), or actually read a book.

As therapists, we go to therapy. It is part of our training, and it becomes a routine part of how we take care of ourselves. By the time I received that diagnosis, I had already been in therapy for years. This unsurfaced struggle continued to swirl in the background, visible only to those who had access to my bedroom closet. Receiving the diagnosis was not a judgment or a setback. It was freedom. It brought clarity. It made so many things make sense.

Engaging in therapy both before and after that moment allows me to recognize when those struggles show up, to understand how they affect me, and to stay connected to who I am and how I want to live. Therapy was never just a reaction to difficulty. It was, and continues to be, a resource. It is one of the ways I take care of myself. I often tell people that when it comes to therapy, I am a lifer. Without a doubt, I will return to it at different points in my life, not because I need it to survive, but because it helps me stay grounded and aligned with myself.

A formal diagnosis, however, is not the threshold for seeking help. Many people do not meet full diagnostic criteria. What they do have is a quiet, persistent sense that something about their life is not unfolding the way they hoped it would. Their marriage feels more functional than connected. Parenting feels more draining than joyful. Their days are full, but not deeply satisfying.

That internal whisper, the one that says, “Maybe it could feel different,” is worth listening to.

Therapy gives you a space to speak that whisper out loud and begin to understand it. It is a guided process, but it is also a deeply personal one. Together with a therapist, you begin to notice what patterns you are carrying, where they come from, and how they are showing up in your relationships, your parenting, your daily life. Whether the source is external or internal, rooted in your environment, your cognitive patterns, your nervous system or physical health, or in the coping strategies you have spent a lifetime developing, therapy helps uncover what lies beneath. These often include inherited burdens, limiting narratives, or unconscious expectations about closeness and connection.Some days it feels like insight. Other days it feels like relief. Over time, it becomes a relationship that helps you come back to yourself, again and again.

We do not need to be in crisis to benefit from deeper insight. Sometimes we seek therapy not because anything is wrong, but because something inside us knows it could be more right. We could feel more present. More connected. More like ourselves.

If that resonates with you or with someone you care about, it is not too late to ask deeper questions. It is never too soon to begin the conversation.

Mental Health Support Is for Everyone

At CNY Mental Health Counseling, nearly 65 percent of the individuals we support are adults navigating relationships, parenting, career demands, and life transitions.

Our therapists work with individuals, couples, parent-child pairs, siblings, and even colleagues. Mental health is relational. It affects how we show up in every area of life.

You do not need a diagnosis or a crisis to benefit from support. Often, the most meaningful work begins with a quiet realization: “This just is not how I hoped it would feel.”

You are allowed to explore that. We are here to help. And, your future self will thank you.